Project access without login (via a token or QRCode)
looking for funding
S
Sam Woodcock
Currently 'public' projects allow public viewing, but not public editing.
In certain cases it would be really useful to edit a project from a team of mappers, without requiring any sort of login.
The ideal workflow would be:
One user downloads the project from QField cloud web via QRCode --> the user shares the QRCode with the mapping team / colleagues --> all users can load the project and edit geometries / attributes freely.
If it's a truly public mapping campaign, such as mapping geometries for OpenStreetMap, I don't see this as an issue. The geoms will be validated prior to any upload to OpenStreetMap.
S
Sam Woodcock
For anyone viewing this, I just wanted to add that QField had some updates that go some way to solving the problem:
- Public projects can have users contribute, without explicitly adding them to the project.
- Now a project can be made public, a default role set, and any user in the QFC instance is given that role by default (make it an editor if you wish).
For workflows in developing countries, where tools like ODK and Kobo (+-Commcare, DHIS2) really dominate, the issue posted here is the default. Giving users access by simple means, often via a QRCode scan. In many scenarios, mappers with valuable information to contribute are marginalised due to not having an email address. In mapping campaigns that include local communities, often sign up to a tool is a big blocker during training.
That said, it's great to see QField making some big changes to make the workflows a lot more inclusive over time, so bravo!
I should really keep this thread in mind when considering future work with potential funding 😅
I

Ivan Ivanov
updated the status to
looking for funding
I

Ivan Ivanov
We have put some thoughts how this might be achieved. It is not on our immediate plan for now.
Z

Zsanett Medvei
updated the status to
planned